Educational Freedom Institute

Donate · About · Contact

Time for the School Choice Movement to Embrace the Culture War

Jay P. Greene and James D. Paul

February 9, 2022

Summary

In this Heritage Foundation Backgrounder, Jay P. Greene and James D. Paul argue that school choice advocates should engage in cultural debates over education and present school choice as a solution. They contend that choice gives parents on every side of these debates more control over their children’s education.

The paper analyzes a nationally representative Ipsos survey of 1,632 adults conducted over two weeks in summer 2021, which asked about school choice and about topics such as critical race theory (CRT) and the 1619 Project. Respondents answered three hypothetical school choice questions, and overall they supported school choice and were skeptical of CRT, the 1619 Project and social justice ideology. On each of four culture questions, more than 20 percent of respondents said they were not sure.

Support for choice varied with answers to the cultural questions: on average, 55 percent of those who opposed CRT in the classroom supported school choice, compared with 38 percent of those who were not sure. Using regression models and a series of assumptions, the authors estimate that if the not-sure respondents came to reject radical political views, average support across the three choice questions could rise from 49.5 percent to 53.8 percent.

That estimate is a recalculation under the authors’ assumptions, and the survey measured opinions at a single point in time. The paper’s recommendations for advocacy groups are the authors’ argument.

Key findings

Among 1,632 adults surveyed in summer 2021, those who opposed CRT in the classroom supported school choice more often than those unsure about it, 55 percent to 38 percent on average. Under stated assumptions, the authors estimate average choice support could rise from 49.5 to 53.8 percent if unsure respondents rejected radical views.

Questions and answers

What does the paper argue?

That school choice advocates should engage in cultural debates and offer choice as a solution parents on all sides can use.

What did the survey find?

Respondents generally supported school choice, and those who rejected radical critiques of America were the most supportive.

Does the paper show that messaging changes minds?

The 49.5 to 53.8 percent figure is a recalculation under the authors’ assumptions. The survey measured opinions at one point in time.

Who published it?

The Heritage Foundation, as Backgrounder No. 3683.

Do people who oppose CRT support school choice?

Under the authors’ stated assumptions, average support for three school choice scenarios would rise from 49.5% to 53.8% if respondents who were unsure about CRT, the 1619 Project and related questions came to reject those positions. That figure is an assumption-based projection, not a causal finding that persuasion changes support.

Read the paper

Read the full report (PDF): Time for the School Choice Movement to Embrace the Culture War

Cite this study

Greene, Jay P., and James D. Paul. (February 9, 2022). Time for the School Choice Movement to Embrace the Culture War. Backgrounder No. 3683. The Heritage Foundation. https://www.efinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/EFI-SchoolChoiceCultureWars_Heritage.pdf