Benjamin Scafidi and Eric Wearne, Education Economics Center, Kennesaw State University
December 2021 (2022 edition)
This is the ECER 2022 edition (the report is dated December 2021). For the latest edition, see ECER 2024.
Summary
ECER 2022, by Benjamin Scafidi and Eric Wearne of the Education Economics Center at Kennesaw State University, ranks state charter school ecosystems by outcomes for students. Earlier rankings by the National Association of Charter School Authorizers (NACSA) and the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools (NAPCS) scored states largely on how closely their laws matched policies experts considered wise; the authors argue those rankings do not account for how many students can reach charter schools or how those schools perform. This edition updates the authors’ June 2021 concept paper with newer data.
The ranking combines three access measures with two performance measures. Access is measured by the share of public school students enrolled in charter schools, the share living in a ZIP code with a charter school and the one-year increase in charter enrollment share. Performance is measured by cohort-based and value-added growth in math and reading, using Stanford Educational Opportunity Project data, and the two performance measures are double-weighted. Access data are from 2018-19, and performance data run through 2017-18. Data limits allowed the authors to rank 35 states, including Washington, DC.
DC, Arizona, Louisiana and Oklahoma ranked highest, while Hawaii, Massachusetts, Colorado and Maryland ranked lowest. The authors say the rankings describe statewide ecosystems and should not be read as a judgment on individual charter schools in lower-ranked states. The results reflect this edition’s data and measures, and the report says it makes no prejudgment about why or how particular laws or policies work.
Key findings
ECER 2022 ranks 35 states, including DC, on charter school access and student learning growth, using 2018-19 access data and performance data through 2017-18. DC, Arizona, Louisiana and Oklahoma ranked highest. The rankings are an edition-specific snapshot of statewide ecosystems; they do not rate individual schools or estimate what specific laws cause.
Questions and answers
How is ECER different from other charter rankings?
Earlier NACSA and NAPCS rankings scored states mainly on their policies. ECER 2022 ranks states on charter access and student learning gains.
What data does it use?
Access measures from 2018-19 and Stanford Educational Opportunity Project performance measures through 2017-18, with performance double-weighted.
Why aren’t all states ranked?
Some states had no charter schools, and some lacked the test data needed to estimate charter learning gains.
Does a low rank mean a state’s charter schools are bad?
No. The authors say charter schools in lower-ranking states should not be considered necessarily bad schools.
Read the paper
Read the full report (PDF): ECER 2022: EFI Charter School Ecosystem Rankings
Cite this study
Scafidi, Benjamin, and Eric Wearne. (December 2021). ECER 2022: EFI Charter School Ecosystem Rankings. Educational Freedom Institute. https://www.efinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/EFI-ECER2022f.pdf
