Educational Freedom Institute

Donate · About · Contact

Working Paper #9-2020

The Case Against The Case Against Homeschooling

By Peter Gray

Peter Gray, PhD, Research Professor of Psychology at Boston College and Founder of the Alliance for Self-directed Education, presented a lecture during a conference titled “The Disinformation Campaign Against Homeschooling.” This working paper is based on the lecture he delivered at the conference on May 1, 2020. The event was sponsored by “Ideological Diversity,” a student organization at Harvard University.

Questions and answers

Should homeschooling be banned?

This working paper is Peter Gray’s rebuttal to Elizabeth Bartholet’s case for banning or severely regulating homeschooling. Gray argues that, on the available evidence, outlawing homeschooling would increase rather than reduce total harm to children: “On the basis of available evidence, it is absurd to believe, as Bartholet apparently does, that the total amount of hurt done to children would go down rather than up if homeschooling were outlawed.”