Educational Freedom Institute

Donate · About · Contact

Working Paper #3-2022

The Relationship Between Regulation and Charter School Innovation

By Ian Kingsbury, Jay P. Greene, Corey A. DeAngelis

Dr. Ian Kingsbury, Dr. Jay Greene, and Dr. Corey DeAngelis discuss the relationship between the most common regulations placed on charter schools and innovation among those schools in their approaches to pedagogy, methodology, and other characteristics.

Questions and answers

Does regulation reduce charter school innovation?

Kingsbury, Greene and DeAngelis find that a 1-point increase in a state’s NACSA authorizing-policy score is associated with about 0.015 standard deviations less innovation among newly opened charter schools. That association is suggestive, not a causal estimate. The curriculum component is an exception: the relationship between curriculum innovation and regulation is significant and positive, which the authors tie to a higher prevalence of language immersion and International Baccalaureate programs in more highly regulated states.