Educational Freedom Institute

Donate · About · Contact

EFI Charter School Ecosystem Rankings | ECER 2024

Benjamin Scafidi and Eric Wearne, Education Economics Center, Kennesaw State University

April 2024

Summary

ECER 2024, by Benjamin Scafidi and Eric Wearne of the Education Economics Center at Kennesaw State University, updates the authors’ 2021 and 2022 rankings of state charter school ecosystems. Like the earlier editions, it ranks states on outcomes for students: how accessible charter schools are and how charter students perform on state reading and math exams compared with the traditional public schools they otherwise would have attended.

This edition uses 2021-22 data for two access measures: the share of public school students enrolled in a charter school and the share who attend school in a ZIP code with a charter school serving their grade level. Its performance measures come from CREDO’s 2023 National Charter School Study III. Reading and math performance together carry 60 percent of the weight and access carries 40 percent. Thirty states, including Washington, DC, had the complete data needed to be ranked.

Rhode Island ranked first, driven by the strongest academic results among the ranked states. The authors describe the ECER as a statewide first pass and a snapshot of one point in time that may not reflect a specific community or where a state’s charter ecosystem is headed. They caution readers not to denigrate charter schools in lower-ranked states, and the results describe this edition’s measures, not the effect of any particular law.

Key findings

ECER 2024 ranks 30 states, including DC, on charter school access, using 2021-22 data, and on reading and math performance from CREDO’s 2023 study, with performance weighted at 60 percent. Rhode Island ranked first. The authors call the rankings a statewide first pass and a snapshot in time; they do not rate individual schools.

Questions and answers

What changed from earlier editions?

Newer data: 2021-22 access measures and performance measures from CREDO’s 2023 National Charter School Study III.

How are states scored?

States earn points by rank on four measures, and reading and math count 1.5 times, giving performance 60 percent of the weight.

Why are only 30 states ranked?

Some states had no charter schools, some did not share test data with CREDO and some had too few or too new charter schools.

How should families use it?

As a first pass. A nearby charter school may still be the best option for a family in a low-ranked state.

Which states have the best charter school ecosystems?

In ECER 2024, Rhode Island ranks first with 130 ECER points, followed by New York, Michigan and Washington, DC. South Carolina ranks last of the 30 states with complete CREDO data. This is a ranking of state charter sectors, not of individual schools. States ranked low are not, on that basis, said to have bad charter schools. Do not compare these ranks with ECER 2022 as if the editions used the same weights and data.

Earlier editions: ECER 2022 companion and the 2021 beta, labeled as earlier editions.

Read the paper

Read the full report (PDF): EFI Charter School Ecosystem Rankings | ECER 2024

Cite this study

Scafidi, Benjamin, and Eric Wearne. (April 2024). EFI Charter School Ecosystem Rankings | ECER 2024. Educational Freedom Institute. https://www.efinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/EFI-ECER2024.pdf